Understanding how puerto rico taxes to us obligations work can mean the difference between keeping thousands of dollars and handing them over unnecessarily. If you’re considering a move to Puerto Rico or already living there, the tax implications are far more nuanced than most people realize. Let me walk you through exactly what you need to know.
Table of Contents
Puerto Rico Tax Basics
Puerto Rico operates under a unique tax system that’s fundamentally different from the mainland United States. As a U.S. territory, PR has its own tax authority—the Puerto Rico Department of Treasury—which administers local taxes separate from the IRS. This is where the real opportunity lies.
Here’s the core concept: Puerto Rico residents who meet specific requirements can pay dramatically lower tax rates on certain types of income. We’re talking about 0% capital gains tax, 4% corporate tax, and 37% top marginal rate on ordinary income (compared to 37% federal alone). But here’s the catch—you have to actually qualify as a PR resident, and the IRS doesn’t make this easy.
The local tax system includes income tax, corporate tax, capital gains tax, and various other levies. Puerto Rico’s government has created incentive programs specifically designed to attract high-net-worth individuals and business owners. These aren’t loopholes; they’re legitimate tax policies enacted by the PR government.
Act 20 & Act 60 Incentives Explained
In 2012, Puerto Rico passed Act 20 (now incorporated into Act 60), which offers extraordinary tax benefits to eligible individuals. This law provides a 4% flat tax rate on business income for those who establish a PR business and meet residency requirements. Act 60 also includes provisions for capital gains taxation at 0%—yes, zero percent—on gains from investments made after establishing PR residency.
The catch? You need to establish bona fide residency in Puerto Rico. This means you can’t just claim PR residency on paper while living in Manhattan. The IRS and PR tax authorities have become increasingly scrutinous about enforcement.
Many high-income professionals—entrepreneurs, investors, real estate professionals—have legitimately moved to Puerto Rico and saved millions in taxes. But the path requires genuine relocation, not tax fiction. You’ll need to spend more than 183 days in PR annually, establish a home there, and demonstrate ties to the island.
One important note: Act 20/60 benefits don’t apply to W-2 employees or passive investment income unless specific conditions are met. Self-employed individuals and business owners see the greatest benefit.
Federal Tax Obligations for PR Residents
Here’s where many people get confused: moving to Puerto Rico doesn’t eliminate your federal tax obligations entirely. However, it can dramatically reduce them.
If you establish bona fide PR residency, you generally only pay federal taxes on PR-source income and certain U.S.-source income (like Social Security or pension income). Income earned from your PR business? That’s taxed locally, not federally. Investment gains on PR-based investments? Local tax treatment applies.
However, if you’re a U.S. citizen (which most PR residents are), you’ll still file federal returns. The key is that your PR-source income gets excluded from federal taxation through the Puerto Rico Act 933 (for bona fide residents), which excludes PR-source income from federal taxation.
This is where understanding the interaction between PR law and federal law becomes critical. Many people assume they pay nothing federally—that’s incorrect. You pay federal taxes on non-PR-source income, but your business income, capital gains, and PR investments get favorable treatment under PR law.
Establishing Bona Fide Residency
The IRS doesn’t accept casual claims of PR residency. You need to document your move thoroughly. Bona fide residency requires:
- Physical presence: More than 183 days in PR per calendar year (with specific counting rules)
- Housing: Establish a permanent home in PR that you actually occupy
- Ties to the island: Employment, business operations, family connections, or community involvement
- Severing mainland ties: Sell your home, change your driver’s license, update voter registration, move your banking
- Documentation: Keep detailed records of your days in PR, lease agreements, utility bills, and business records
The IRS scrutinizes PR moves heavily. They’re looking for people who claim residency while maintaining significant mainland connections. If you own property in Florida, keep your mainland business running, and spend 200 days in the U.S., the IRS will challenge your PR residency claim.
Start your PR residency the right way: actually move there. Establish a genuine business or employment. Get involved in the community. The tax benefits are real, but they require real relocation.
The Bona Fide Residency Test
The IRS uses a multi-factor test to determine if you’re a bona fide PR resident. This isn’t just about days spent on the island—it’s about your overall situation.
The 183-day rule: You must be present in PR for more than 183 days during the tax year. But there are exceptions. Days you’re in PR for medical treatment don’t count. Days you’re there temporarily for a specific event might not count. The IRS looks at the nature and purpose of your presence.
Primary residence test: Your main home must be in PR. If you own multiple properties, the IRS determines which is your primary residence based on where you spend the most time, where your family lives, and where you conduct business.
Economic ties: Where do you work? Where is your business? Where do you have financial interests? If you’re earning significant income from mainland sources while claiming PR residency, that creates problems.
Social ties: Do you have family in PR? Are you involved in community activities? Do you have friends there? This sounds subjective, but the IRS considers it alongside objective factors.
The IRS has specific guidance on this (see IRS.gov for Publication 570), and they’ve become aggressive about challenging questionable claims. If you’re serious about PR residency, consult a PR tax attorney before making the move.
IRS Reporting Requirements
Once you establish PR residency, you still have filing obligations. Here’s what you need to know:
Federal returns: You file Form 1040 with the IRS, but you claim the PR Act 933 exclusion for PR-source income. This excludes qualifying income from federal taxation.
PR returns: You file a PR tax return with the Department of Treasury. This includes your PR-source income and is subject to PR tax rates (which are lower than federal rates for many income types).
FBAR requirements: If you have foreign financial accounts exceeding $10,000, you must file an FBAR (FinCEN Form 114). PR isn’t foreign, but accounts in other countries are.
Form 8898: If you’re claiming PR residency status for the first time, you must file Form 8898 with your federal return. This form notifies the IRS of your PR residency claim.
State returns: You don’t file returns in any U.S. state if you’re a bona fide PR resident. This is another significant benefit—no state income tax on top of federal.
The reporting is straightforward if you’re organized. Keep meticulous records of your days in PR, your income sources, and your PR business activities. Investopedia’s guide on tax residency provides additional context on how residency affects taxation.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
I’ve seen people make costly errors with PR residency. Here are the big ones:
Mistake #1: Maintaining a mainland home. Selling your U.S. property is painful, but keeping it signals that PR isn’t your primary residence. The IRS uses this as evidence against your claim.
Mistake #2: Inconsistent days in PR. If you claim 200+ days in PR but your credit card statements show you spent half the year in New York, the IRS will catch this. Track your days meticulously.
Mistake #3: Failing to file Form 8898. This form notifies the IRS of your residency claim. Failing to file it can result in the IRS denying your entire Act 933 exclusion claim.
Mistake #4: Not establishing a genuine business. If you move to PR but continue earning W-2 income from a mainland employer, you don’t qualify for Act 60 benefits on that income. You need PR-source income.
Mistake #5: Ignoring PR tax compliance. Some people think they can claim PR residency without filing PR tax returns. Wrong. You need to file both PR and federal returns (with exclusions) to maintain your residency status.
Mistake #6: Moving back too soon. Act 933 requires you to be a PR resident for the entire tax year you claim the exclusion. Moving back to the mainland mid-year disqualifies you for that year.
These mistakes can cost you dearly—not just in taxes owed, but in penalties and interest. Get professional advice before making the move.
Strategic Tax Planning for PR Residents
If you’re seriously considering PR residency, here’s how to structure your move for maximum tax efficiency:
Timing your move: Move to PR early in the year to maximize days spent there. A January move is better than a November move. You want to clearly satisfy the 183-day requirement.
Structuring your income: If you’re self-employed, consider establishing a PR corporation or LLC. This allows you to pay PR corporate tax rates (4% under Act 60) rather than higher federal rates. Work with a PR tax professional on the right structure.
Investment planning: Investments made after establishing PR residency receive favorable capital gains treatment. Plan your investment timing accordingly. Gains on pre-residency investments still face federal taxation.
Pension and retirement income: Certain types of retirement income get favorable treatment in PR. If you’re planning to retire, the timing of your move matters significantly.
Real estate considerations: Real property in PR gets special treatment under Act 60. If you’re considering real estate investments, PR offers advantages. However, you need genuine PR residency to access these benefits.
Work with a CPA and tax attorney experienced in PR taxation. The upfront cost of professional advice will pay for itself many times over through proper planning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I claim PR residency if I own property on the mainland?
Technically yes, but it’s risky. The IRS considers property ownership as evidence of ties to that location. If you own a home in Florida and claim PR residency, the IRS will scrutinize your claim heavily. Most people establishing PR residency sell their mainland properties to eliminate this issue.
What happens if the IRS denies my PR residency claim?
If the IRS denies your claim, you’ll owe federal taxes on all income you claimed was PR-source, plus penalties and interest. This can be devastating financially. This is why proper documentation and professional guidance before making the move is essential.
Do Puerto Rico residents pay federal income tax?
Bona fide PR residents pay federal tax only on non-PR-source income. PR-source business income, capital gains on PR investments, and PR-based employment income are generally excluded from federal taxation under Act 933. However, you still file federal returns to report and exclude this income.
Is Act 60 still available?
Yes, Act 60 (which replaced Act 20 and Act 20/22) is still in effect, though some provisions have been modified. The 4% corporate tax rate and capital gains benefits remain available for qualifying individuals. However, eligibility requirements have become stricter, and the IRS has increased enforcement.
How long must I stay in Puerto Rico?
You must maintain bona fide residency to keep your tax benefits. This means continuing to satisfy the 183-day requirement, maintaining your primary residence in PR, and keeping your economic ties to the island. If you move back to the mainland, your benefits end.
Can I use PR residency if I’m a W-2 employee?
Act 60 benefits primarily apply to self-employed individuals and business owners. W-2 employees generally don’t qualify for the 4% corporate tax rate. However, if you’re a PR resident earning W-2 income from a PR employer, that income may receive favorable treatment. The rules are complex—consult a PR tax professional.
What’s the difference between PR residency and U.S. residency?
PR residency is a specific tax status recognized by Puerto Rico and the IRS. You can be a U.S. citizen and a PR resident—these aren’t mutually exclusive. U.S. residency typically refers to having a permanent home in the U.S., which conflicts with PR residency claims.
Summary: Making Your PR Tax Decision
Understanding how puerto rico taxes to us obligations work is crucial if you’re considering a move to the island. The tax benefits are real and substantial—but they require genuine relocation, not tax fiction.
Here’s the bottom line: If you’re self-employed or a business owner with high income, PR residency can save you hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. But you must:
- Actually move to Puerto Rico and establish genuine residency
- Document your days on the island meticulously
- Sever mainland ties (sell your home, change your address, etc.)
- Establish PR-source income through a business or employment
- File both PR and federal tax returns properly
- Maintain compliance with Act 60 requirements
The IRS has become increasingly aggressive about auditing PR residency claims. They’re specifically looking for people who claim PR residency while maintaining significant mainland connections or failing to establish genuine PR businesses.
If you’re serious about this, work with a Puerto Rico tax attorney and CPA before making the move. The cost of professional guidance (typically $3,000-$10,000) is trivial compared to the potential savings—or the potential penalties if you get it wrong.
For additional context on related tax planning strategies, you might explore donor-advised fund tax deduction strategies or review information about tax ID requirements for estates, which can be relevant for comprehensive wealth planning.
The opportunity is real, but so are the risks of getting it wrong. Do it right, and you’ll enjoy legitimate tax savings for years. Do it wrong, and you’ll face an IRS audit you won’t forget.
