Understanding the tax on MYGA withdrawal is crucial for anyone holding a Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity, as the tax implications can significantly impact your retirement income and overall financial plan. Unlike traditional savings accounts, MYGAs carry specific tax consequences that many investors overlook until withdrawal time arrives.
Table of Contents
What Is a MYGA Annuity?
A Multi-Year Guaranteed Annuity is a fixed annuity product that guarantees a specific interest rate for a predetermined period—typically ranging from three to ten years. You deposit a lump sum, the insurance company invests it, and you receive guaranteed returns. Think of it as a bridge between a CD and a traditional annuity, offering predictability without the complexity of variable products.
MYGAs appeal to conservative investors seeking stable, predictable growth. However, the tax treatment differs significantly from regular savings accounts. The earnings generated within the MYGA are tax-deferred until you withdraw them, but when withdrawal time comes, you’ll owe taxes on those gains—and potentially penalties too.
How MYGA Taxation Works
The fundamental principle: you only pay taxes on the earnings, not your original principal. If you invested $100,000 and it grew to $115,000, you’d owe taxes on $15,000, not the full amount. This distinction matters because it affects your actual tax liability.
MYGAs use a “last in, first out” (LIFO) withdrawal method, meaning earnings come out first when you take distributions. This is different from some other investment vehicles and can trigger larger immediate tax bills if you need to access your funds early. The tax rate applied depends on your overall income situation and whether the MYGA is qualified or nonqualified—a distinction we’ll explore shortly.
Early Withdrawal Penalties Explained
Here’s where things get painful: withdrawing from your MYGA before the guarantee period ends typically triggers surrender charges imposed by the insurance company. These aren’t IRS penalties—they’re contractual fees that reduce your withdrawal amount. A typical surrender charge might be 7-10% in year one, declining by 1% annually until it reaches zero.
Beyond surrender charges, if you’re under age 59½ and withdraw from a nonqualified MYGA, the IRS adds a 10% early withdrawal penalty on the earnings portion. This compounds your tax burden significantly. For example, a $50,000 withdrawal of earnings could face a $5,000 IRS penalty plus surrender charges—before income taxes even enter the picture.
Qualified MYGAs (those funded with retirement account money) have different early withdrawal rules. If held within an IRA or 401(k), the 10% penalty applies differently, and you must follow AGI-related distribution rules that affect your overall tax return.
Ordinary Income Tax Treatment
MYGA earnings are taxed as ordinary income, not capital gains. This is significant because ordinary income rates are typically higher than long-term capital gains rates. If you’re in the 24% federal tax bracket, your MYGA earnings face that 24% rate, unlike stock investments that might qualify for the 15% or 20% long-term capital gains rate.
The earnings portion of your MYGA withdrawal gets added to your other income for the year, potentially pushing you into a higher tax bracket—a phenomenon called “bracket creep.” A large MYGA withdrawal combined with other income sources could trigger higher Medicare premiums, loss of tax credits, or increased taxation of Social Security benefits. This is why timing your withdrawals strategically matters tremendously.
Understanding Surrender Charges
Surrender charges are the insurance company’s way of protecting their investment in you. When you buy a MYGA, the company invests your money in bonds and other fixed-income securities. If you pull out early, they’re forced to liquidate those positions, potentially at a loss.
A typical surrender schedule might look like this: 7% in year one, 6% in year two, declining to 0% by year eight. Some MYGAs have longer or shorter schedules. Importantly, surrender charges apply to your withdrawal amount, not just the earnings. If you withdraw $100,000 early from year one, you might receive only $93,000 after a 7% charge.
The silver lining: once you reach the end of the guarantee period, surrender charges disappear. You can withdraw your money penalty-free. Many investors plan their cash needs around this window to avoid unnecessary charges.
Qualified vs. Nonqualified MYGAs
This distinction fundamentally changes your tax situation. A qualified MYGA is funded with pre-tax retirement account money—think IRA rollovers or 401(k) transfers. A nonqualified MYGA uses after-tax dollars from your regular savings.
With qualified MYGAs, your entire withdrawal is taxable (assuming you haven’t made nondeductible contributions). You’ve already gotten the tax deduction when you contributed, so the IRS wants its share when you take money out. These withdrawals count toward your adjusted gross income (AGI), affecting tax credits and deductions.
Nonqualified MYGAs offer better tax efficiency because only earnings are taxable. Your principal comes out tax-free. However, the LIFO method means you exhaust earnings before accessing principal, so early withdrawals trigger larger tax bills proportionally.
Strategies to Minimize Tax Burden
Smart planning can substantially reduce your MYGA tax hit. First, time your withdrawals strategically. If you’re in a lower income year—perhaps you took early retirement or had reduced business income—that’s an ideal time to withdraw MYGA earnings and pay lower rates.
Second, consider laddering your MYGAs. Instead of one large MYGA maturing all at once, spread your investments across multiple products with staggered maturity dates. This lets you withdraw gradually, staying in lower tax brackets.
Third, evaluate Roth conversions. If you have a qualified MYGA in an IRA, converting it to a Roth IRA lets you pay taxes now at known rates, then withdraw tax-free later. This works best in low-income years.
Fourth, coordinate with other income sources. If you’re taking Social Security, managing capital gains, or receiving investment income, coordinate MYGA withdrawals to minimize overall tax liability. A tax professional can model scenarios showing optimal withdrawal timing.
Finally, hold nonqualified MYGAs long-term. If possible, keep them until the guarantee period ends to eliminate surrender charges, maximizing the amount available for withdrawal.
State Tax Implications
Don’t overlook state income taxes. While a few states don’t tax income, most will tax your MYGA earnings at rates ranging from 2-13%. Some states offer preferential treatment for retirement income, potentially excluding MYGA withdrawals if you’re over 59½. Others tax all MYGA earnings regardless of age.
If you’re considering relocating in retirement, MYGA taxation could influence your decision. Moving from California (13% state income tax) to Florida (no state income tax) could save thousands on MYGA withdrawals. Similarly, understanding state-specific tax rules helps you plan appropriately.
Some states tax the interest earned but not the principal, similar to federal treatment. Others tax everything. Check your specific state’s rules—your state tax authority’s website provides clear guidance.
Required Minimum Distributions
If your qualified MYGA sits in an IRA or inherited retirement account, Required Minimum Distributions (RMDs) apply. Starting at age 73 (as of 2023, per SECURE 2.0 Act changes), you must withdraw at least a calculated percentage of your IRA balance annually.
The RMD calculation uses IRS life expectancy tables and your account balance. If you fail to take your RMD, the penalty is harsh—50% of the shortfall amount (though this was temporarily reduced under recent legislation). These distributions are fully taxable for qualified accounts, adding to your annual income.
If you don’t need the RMD money, consider a Qualified Charitable Distribution (QCD) if you’re charitably inclined. You can transfer up to $100,000 annually directly to qualified charities, satisfying your RMD without increasing your taxable income.
Frequently Asked Questions
Do I owe taxes on my MYGA principal?
No. Taxes apply only to earnings—the growth your principal generated. Your original investment comes out tax-free. The IRS only wants its cut of the gains.
What’s the 10% early withdrawal penalty?
If you’re under 59½ and withdraw from a nonqualified MYGA, the IRS charges 10% on the earnings portion as a penalty for early access. Qualified accounts have different rules but may also face penalties depending on your age and account type.
Can I avoid surrender charges?
Yes—wait until the guarantee period ends. Most MYGAs allow penalty-free withdrawals once the term expires. If you need access sooner, you’ll pay the surrender charge, which typically ranges from 5-10% of your withdrawal.
Are MYGA earnings taxed differently than CD interest?
No. Both are taxed as ordinary income. However, MYGAs offer tax deferral—you don’t owe taxes until withdrawal. CDs tax you annually on interest earned, even if you don’t withdraw it.
Should I withdraw my entire MYGA at once?
Usually not. Large lump-sum withdrawals can push you into higher tax brackets and trigger other tax consequences. Spreading withdrawals over multiple years typically results in lower overall tax liability.
How does a MYGA withdrawal affect Social Security taxation?
MYGA earnings count toward your “combined income” for Social Security taxation purposes. Large withdrawals can cause up to 85% of your Social Security benefits to become taxable. Coordinating MYGA withdrawals with Social Security claiming strategy is essential.
