Uncertain tax positions are claims or deductions you take on your tax return where the tax treatment isn’t completely clear under current law. Think of them as the gray areas of the tax code—situations where you’re reasonably confident in your position, but you know the IRS might disagree. Understanding how to identify, document, and disclose these positions is crucial for staying compliant and avoiding costly penalties.
Table of Contents
What Are Uncertain Positions?
Uncertain tax positions exist in the space between what you’re claiming on your return and what the IRS would accept without question. These aren’t illegal positions—they’re legitimate claims that have some level of ambiguity. For example, you might deduct home office expenses using a calculation method that’s defensible but not the standard approach. Or you might claim a business loss in a year when your venture was genuinely struggling, but the IRS might later argue it was a hobby.
The key distinction is this: you must believe your position has substantial authority under the tax law. That means there’s a reasonable basis for your claim, even if the IRS might challenge it. It’s not a guess or a hope—it’s a calculated position backed by at least some interpretation of the tax code.
Why They Matter for Compliance
The IRS takes uncertain tax positions seriously because they represent potential revenue loss. Since 2009, companies and individuals have been required to account for uncertain tax positions under specific rules. If you’re preparing financial statements or dealing with corporate tax matters, this becomes even more critical. The Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) requires that uncertain tax positions be evaluated and disclosed in certain circumstances.
For individual filers, the stakes are different but still significant. Taking an uncertain position without proper documentation or disclosure could result in audit adjustments, interest charges, and penalties. The IRS has become increasingly sophisticated at identifying aggressive positions, especially those that appear in multiple returns or follow a pattern.
Identifying Uncertain Positions
So how do you know if you’re dealing with an uncertain tax position? Ask yourself these questions:
- Would a tax professional agree with this interpretation without hesitation?
- Is there any ambiguity in how the tax code applies to my situation?
- Could the IRS reasonably interpret this differently than I have?
- Am I using a method or approach that’s less common than alternatives?
- Is this position supported by tax court cases or IRS guidance?
Common examples include claiming deductions for business entertainment (the rules changed significantly), home office deductions using non-standard calculations, or charitable contributions of non-cash items where valuation is subjective. Another frequent area involves determining whether income qualifies as tax exempt interest income, which requires careful analysis of the underlying investment.
Self-employed individuals often encounter uncertain positions when determining business expenses. If you’re filing a Schedule SE tax form, you need to be particularly careful about what you’re claiming as legitimate business deductions versus personal expenses.
Documentation Requirements
Documentation is your best defense. For any uncertain position, you should maintain thorough records that demonstrate:
- The facts: What actually happened? Document dates, amounts, and circumstances.
- Your reasoning: Why did you take this position? What tax code sections or regulations support it?
- Alternative approaches: What other methods could apply, and why did you choose yours?
- Professional consultation: Did you consult a tax professional? Keep those communications and advice.
For business owners, this means keeping emails, invoices, receipts, and contemporaneous notes. For individuals, it means more than just the numbers on your return—it means showing your work. If you claimed a deduction for home office space, document the square footage, the business use percentage, and how you calculated your deduction.
The documentation burden is real, but it’s far lighter than the burden of defending yourself during an audit without it. The IRS assumes that if you can’t document something, it didn’t happen.
Disclosure Strategies
Disclosure is a nuanced decision. For individual tax returns, you’re not always required to disclose uncertain positions, but there are circumstances where you should consider it. If a position is particularly aggressive or lacks substantial authority, disclosing it on Form 8275 (Disclosure Statement) or Form 8275-R (Regulation Disclosure Statement) can actually work in your favor.
Why? Because disclosure demonstrates good faith. It shows the IRS that you’re not trying to hide anything—you’re being transparent about the fact that you’re taking a position with some ambiguity. While this doesn’t guarantee the IRS won’t challenge it, it can reduce penalties if they do. The difference between a 20% accuracy-related penalty and a 75% fraud penalty can be substantial.
For those managing estimated quarterly tax payments, understanding uncertain positions becomes relevant when calculating what you owe. If you’re unsure about your tax liability, you might wonder about whether you can have estimated taxes autodrafted with adjustments for uncertain positions built in.
Penalties and Consequences
If the IRS challenges an uncertain position and you lose, you’re facing multiple consequences. First, there’s the additional tax owed on the disallowed amount. Then comes interest—calculated from the original due date of your return. Finally, there are penalties.
The accuracy-related penalty is typically 20% of the underpayment. But if the IRS determines your position lacked substantial authority and you didn’t disclose it, that penalty applies. If they determine it was fraudulent or grossly negligent, penalties can reach 75%. These numbers add up quickly on substantial amounts.
There’s also the audit itself—time-consuming, stressful, and expensive if you need professional representation. And if an uncertain position appears on multiple years of returns, the IRS might see it as a pattern, triggering more aggressive scrutiny.
When to Seek Professional Help
You should consult a tax professional if:
- You’re considering taking a position you’re unsure about
- Your situation involves significant amounts of money
- The tax treatment is genuinely ambiguous
- You’ve never encountered this situation before
- You’re a business owner or have complex income sources
A good tax professional can help you evaluate whether a position has substantial authority, what documentation you need, and whether disclosure makes sense. They can also help you understand your AGI on your tax return and how uncertain positions might affect it, which matters if AGI-based limitations apply to deductions or credits you’re claiming.
For business owners, this conversation should happen before you file, not after you get audited. The cost of professional advice upfront is almost always less than the cost of dealing with an audit.
Best Practices for Management
Here’s how to handle uncertain tax positions like a pro:
Be honest with yourself first. Don’t convince yourself a position is solid when you know it’s shaky. The emotional appeal of a deduction doesn’t make it defensible.
Document everything contemporaneously. Don’t reconstruct records a year later when you get an audit notice. Document as you go.
Understand the tax code. Read the actual regulation, not just a summary. Look at tax court cases that address similar situations. The more you understand, the better your position.
Consider the cost-benefit. Is the tax savings worth the audit risk? Sometimes the answer is no, and that’s okay.
Review your positions annually. Tax law changes. A position that was solid last year might be shakier this year. Stay current.
Communicate with your accountant or tax professional. If you’re self-employed or have business income, regular conversations about uncertain positions help you stay compliant. This is especially important when you’re dealing with specialized areas like tax sheltered annuity arrangements or other complex structures.
Think of uncertain tax positions as a conversation with the IRS that might happen years later. Would you be comfortable explaining your reasoning to an auditor? If not, reconsider the position.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between an uncertain position and tax fraud?
An uncertain position is one you believe has a reasonable basis in tax law, even if the IRS might disagree. Tax fraud involves intentional deception—claiming things you know are false or deliberately hiding income. Uncertain positions are about interpretation; fraud is about dishonesty. That said, the line can blur if you’re reckless about whether something is actually defensible.
Do I have to disclose uncertain positions on my individual tax return?
Not always, but you should if the position lacks substantial authority or if you want to reduce potential penalties. The rules differ for businesses and individuals. If you’re unsure, consult a tax professional. Disclosure using Form 8275 is a strategic decision that depends on your specific situation.
Will disclosing an uncertain position cause an audit?
Disclosure doesn’t automatically trigger an audit. In fact, it can reduce penalties if you’re audited. The IRS audits a small percentage of returns regardless. What disclosure does is show good faith, which matters if the position is later challenged.
How long should I keep documentation for uncertain positions?
Keep it for at least seven years. The IRS can go back three years for most audits, but six years if they claim you underreported income by 25% or more. Seven years gives you a safety margin, and for significant positions, keeping records indefinitely isn’t unreasonable.
Can I change my position if I later realize it’s indefensible?
Yes, but you need to file an amended return. The sooner you do this, the better. Filing an amended return before the IRS contacts you looks better than being forced to correct it during an audit. You’ll still owe the tax and interest, but you might avoid penalties.
What should I do if I realize I took an uncertain position on a prior return?
Consult a tax professional immediately. Depending on the situation, you might file an amended return, apply for a statute of limitations extension, or take other corrective action. Don’t ignore it—the IRS has sophisticated matching programs and will likely find the issue eventually.
Moving Forward with Confidence
Uncertain tax positions aren’t inherently wrong or risky—they’re a normal part of navigating a complex tax code. What matters is how you handle them. Document thoroughly, understand your reasoning, consider disclosure strategically, and don’t hesitate to get professional advice.
The goal isn’t to take aggressive positions for the sake of it. The goal is to pay what you legally owe—no more, no less. When you’re uncertain about what you owe, that’s when professional guidance becomes invaluable. A tax professional can help you evaluate your positions, ensure your documentation is solid, and sleep better at night knowing you’ve done things the right way.
Remember: the IRS isn’t looking to trap you. They’re looking for intentional evasion and patterns of aggressive behavior. If you’re taking reasonable positions, documenting them carefully, and being transparent about areas of ambiguity, you’re already ahead of the game. That’s how you stay compliant while still getting every deduction and credit you’re entitled to.
